Life often feels like it's asking us to choose between two roads. One road involves pretending to be someone you’re not until you achieve whatever it is you're aiming for. The other road is about sticking to your true self, but with the risk of never standing out or getting noticed.
Pretending can mess with your head after a while, while staying true to yourself can sometimes leave you feeling invisible. So, which one is better?
Pretending: Fake It ‘Til You Make It
A lot of people subscribe to the "fake it 'til you make it" mindset. It’s about putting on a version of yourself that feels bigger, more polished, or more confident than the real you. The idea is that if you act like the person you want to become, eventually you’ll grow into that role. It works, but it comes with its own set of issues.
Pretending to be something you’re not can get you through doors. When you present yourself as more confident or skilled than you feel, people start treating you differently. Suddenly, you're getting opportunities you wouldn't have if you had just stayed in your shell. This approach does work, at least in the short term, because people respond to the version of you that they see.
- Acting more confident than you feel in a job interview and landing the position, even though you’re not sure you're fully qualified.
- Pretending to know more about a topic in a social setting, just to fit in with the conversation and avoid feeling left out.
- Dressing and speaking in ways that don’t feel quite authentic to you, just to match what others in a certain group expect.
While this can make you more successful or help you achieve things faster, it also has a downside. After a while, pretending starts to weigh on you. You might start to question who you really are.
The pressure of constantly living up to this manufactured version of yourself can get exhausting. It’s hard to relax when you're always playing a role. Over time, this can wear down your mental health, as you’re constantly feeling like an imposter, even if you're getting the results you wanted.
Staying True to Yourself
On the flip side, you'll definitely get a sense of peace by staying true to who you are. But it doesn’t always lead to recognition. In other words, you may feel more comfortable in your own skin, but the world doesn’t always reward comfort. Sometimes, it just feels like no one’s noticing you at all, and that can be frustrating.
Sticking to your true self has a lot of perks—there’s no act to maintain, no role to play. You don’t have to worry about being “found out” or running out of steam because you’re always yourself. You get to be authentic and live without the constant pressure of keeping up appearances. The problem is, authenticity often goes unnoticed, especially in competitive environments where everyone else is doing their best to stand out.
- Not adjusting your personality at work, even if it means you stay in the background while others shine.
- Dressing in a way that feels comfortable to you, even if it’s not on trend or what’s expected in certain situations.
- Refusing to exaggerate your achievements or personality just to fit in with a more ambitious or assertive crowd.
When you stay true to yourself, you don’t have to deal with the internal struggle of pretending. But there’s another kind of frustration that comes with this path—the feeling that you're not really moving forward. You might feel at peace with who you are, but it’s hard to ignore that sinking feeling when you see other people advancing faster by playing the game. You wonder if you're missing out, or if you’re destined to stay in the same place forever while everyone else is getting ahead.
The Conflict Between Peace and Progress
The tension between these two attitudes comes down to this: peace versus progress. Pretending helps you achieve things, but it chips away at your mental state. Staying true to yourself brings comfort but often leaves you feeling like you’re not going anywhere. It’s a tough choice, and most people find themselves swinging between these two paths at different points in their lives.
The tricky part is that pretending often feels like the shortcut. You act like you’ve got it all together, and suddenly things start happening for you. But deep down, the more you fake it, the more disconnected you become from yourself. This disconnection can take a toll, leading to burnout or feelings of emptiness. It’s hard to enjoy your success when you don’t feel like you earned it as your real self.
- Getting that promotion at work but constantly doubting whether you’re really good enough to deserve it.
- Making a lot of new friends but feeling like none of them really know who you are because you’ve been playing a role the whole time.
- Achieving a lot of external success while feeling hollow on the inside because the version of you that’s winning isn’t the real you.
On the other hand, staying true to yourself often feels like the long road. You might not be moving as fast as the people who are pretending, but there’s a quiet satisfaction in knowing you’re doing it your way. The downside is that staying in your comfort zone can sometimes leave you feeling stagnant. While others are climbing the ladder, you’re just… there. You don’t feel the same sense of momentum, and that lack of recognition can feel like you’re not achieving anything.
- Watching others get ahead while you stick to what feels authentic, even though it means you don’t stand out.
- Feeling overlooked at work because you’re not putting on a show or playing up your strengths the way others do.
- Sticking with what feels true to you, but wondering if you're selling yourself short by not trying harder to stand out.
The Queer Tarot: An Inclusive Deck and Guidebook
Tarot deck and guidebook set for LGBTQ+, created by queer and trans artist team Ash + Chess.
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
The Middle Ground Is Hard to Find
Finding a balance between pretending and staying true is tricky. The world tends to reward those who fake it, but that doesn’t mean it’s the best path for everyone. And staying true to yourself feels great, but it’s tough to ignore the external pressures to be more, do more, and achieve more.
Most people end up trying to strike some sort of balance. Maybe they put on a show when necessary, but retreat to their true selves when they’re with people they trust. Or they stay mostly authentic but know when to stretch the truth a little to get by.
- Acting more confident in situations that require it, but not going so far that you lose track of who you are.
- Allowing yourself to exaggerate some qualities when it helps, while staying grounded in what really matters to you.
- Putting on a more polished version of yourself when necessary, but making sure to reconnect with the real you when the moment passes.
In the end, neither path is without its drawbacks. Pretending gives you progress but at a cost, while staying true keeps you grounded but often leaves you feeling like you’re not moving forward. The trick is figuring out how much you’re willing to compromise, and when it’s worth it to be more or less of yourself depending on the situation.
